Here’s a story about a house…or two, the conjoined twins of Lafayette Square.
The Square displays several architectural styles of the late 1800s. An example of a rare one no longer existing was a residence at the corner of Lafayette and Mississippi Avenues. Design was of the Philadelphia style. It constituted a 2 ½ story duplex building. This was set on a high foundation, with one shared wall and main entrances on two different sides.

An anchor for two riverboat pilots
These grand homes began as an investment by Captain Edwin Sheble (1820 – 1904). He was born in Philadelphia, and moved to the Square in 1870. He and his wife then lived at that corner until 1891.

Sheble was a noteworthy resident. He worked on riverboats since the age of 17, becoming a captain on Indiana’s Wabash River. In the Civil War, he conveyed men and supplies on the Mississippi River. Sheble served under Grant at Vicksburg and Canby at Mobile. He owned or piloted two dozen steamboats during a long career. The captain proved to be a successful businessman. He was president of the McMurray Judge Iron Works, member of the Merchants Exchange, and the board of the Mullanphy Emigrant Relief Society.
His last steamboat was the City of Alton. Upon retiring, he turned the ship over to his river pilot son in law Horace Bixby.
Tutoring America’s author in his youth
A young man with wild hair and a hankering for life on the river came to Sheble in 1857. He offered $500 ($100 of it as cash) for an education in piloting the Mississippi River. Sheble consented and Samuel Clemens learned to be a ‘cub’ pilot under both Sheble and Bixby. Young Mark Twain wrote both Tom Sawyer and Huckleberry Finn while working the river in this capacity. He worked on several boats through 1861. When his steamer took hostile gunfire near Jefferson Barracks in 1861, Bixby reported, “my pilot went west.”

Horace Bixby (1826 – 1912) married Sheble’s daughter, Mary in 1868. Like his father in law, Bixby served as a gunboat pilot on the Mississippi during the Civil War. He then commanded steamboats, plying the rivers as far as Montana. Over a career that continued until his death at the age of 86. Something about working the river graced Bixby and Sheble (as well as Twain, who lived to be 75) with long and full lives.
Back to the house featuring two addresses. Horace and Mary Sheble Bixby owned 1909 Lafayette Avenue from 1882 onward. Edwin and Elizabeth Sheble resided at 1622 Mississippi Avenue.

The Bixbys and the Shebles lived happily in their close proximity. Bixby often leveraged his portion at 1909 Lafayette as collateral for needed capital. As a result, he shared ownership with both the Missouri River Packet Company and the Kansas City Packet Company. Bixby later owned it clear in 1882. He sold to a real estate company a decade later. That half of the mansion rented to Edward Watts Saunders; St Louis’s first pediatric specialist and founder of Bethesda Hospital.
Ownership changes 1891 – 1962
After 1900 Dr. Orion Bedell bought the 1909 side and practiced dentistry there. His operatory chair looked out onto Lafayette Park, In 1917, this half sold and became an upscale rooming house. This was a common fate of the grand old houses of the Square, as the wealthy died out or moved on.
The Shebles owned and occupied 1622 Mississippi until selling to John Hogan in 1891. The next resident was Sigmund Freund, a prosperous dry goods retailer with a big store at Broadway and Carroll Street. The “pallbearer for old mansions,” William Swekosky recalled Freund as a real estate speculator with dozens of holdings along South Broadway. Freund’s children expanded the family business into gas stations and movie theaters, running up the family fortune. Swekosky referred to this as “their weakness; not a bad disease.”
In 1894, Freund bought the 1909 Lafayette half of the house, making him sole owner. His five sons lived in the adjacent Mississippi unit until 1921, when they sold both to Sam Shapiro. 1622 then joined 1909 as a boarding house.

In 1925, Shapiro sold the house to Alex Thodoroff and Theodoro Gork who built a store in front of 1909 Lafayette. You can see part of their store to the left in the photo above. Greek interests in the property continued until Nick Katsaros sold the property in 1962, to Reverend C.L. Morrison of the Gateway Temple Church.

Where things stand today
The house met a wrecking ball the next year. It enabled construction to replace Morrison’s former location, nudged out by I-44 construction. After serving as the church school for years, it relocated to the German House at Lafayette near Jefferson Avenue.
After a decade as a two story brick school, the Gateway Temple School merged with the church at 2345 Lafayette Avenue, a now boarded structure with a terrific history as the German House. The school at the corner of Lafayette and Mississippi was razed in the early 2000’s. Gilded Age turned the lot into Mississippi Place. It’s about as nice a collection of 19th century new homes as you can get.

The most appealing aspect of the house on “Steamboat Corner” today is that the Lawrence Group architects maintained the distinctive Philadelphia style in their version. Well done.
Resources
Working The Mississippi: Two Centuries of Working the River; Bonnie Stepenoff; 2015; University of Missouri Press
House photos and histories aided by summaries of William Swekosky, currently in the Missouri Historical Society. Swekosky wrote his notes in 1962, when the building faced demolition and needed a “pallbearer”.
The St Louis Star and Times of May 26,1943, for a good description of the Philadelphia style and Bixby House. The same paper of May 28, 1943 yielded a good profile of the Sheble House.
I traced some of the routes taken by both Sheble and Bixby by consulting The Steamboat Bertrand And Missouri River Commerce; Ronald Switzer; 2013; University of Oklahoma Press.
For more information on Edward Watts Saunders, have a look at the essay about the Mothers and Babies Camps of Lafayette Park at http://lafayettesquare.org/1918-mothers-and-babies-tent-camps-in-lafayette-park/